Internet use has become ubiquitous in the past two decades, but governments, legislators, and their regulatory agencies have struggled to keep up with the rapidly changing Internet technologies and uses. In this groundbreaking collaboration, regulatory lawyer Christopher Marsden and computer scientist Ian Brown analyze the regulatory shaping of "code" -- the technological environment of the Internet -- to achieve more economically efficient and socially just regulation. They examine five "hard cases" that illustrate the regulatory crisis: privacy and data protection; copyright and creativity incentives; censorship; social networks and user-generated content; and net neutrality. The authors describe the increasing "multistakeholderization" of Internet governance, in which user groups argue for representation in the closed business-government dialogue, seeking to bring in both rights-based and technologically expert perspectives. Brown and Marsden draw out lessons for better future regulation from the regulatory and interoperability failures illustrated by the five cases. They conclude that governments, users, and better functioning markets need a smarter "prosumer law" approach. Prosumer law would be designed to enhance the competitive production of public goods, including innovation, public safety, and fundamental democratic rights.
Cited By
- Marsden C (2017). How law and computer science can work together to improve the information society, Communications of the ACM, 61:1, (29-31), Online publication date: 27-Dec-2017.
- Orwat C and Bless R (2016). Values and Networks, ACM SIGCOMM Computer Communication Review, 46:2, (25-31), Online publication date: 9-Apr-2016.
- Dainow B (2016). Key dialectics in cloud services, ACM SIGCAS Computers and Society, 45:3, (52-59), Online publication date: 5-Jan-2016.
- (2014). IPv4 to IPv6, Telecommunications Policy, 38:11, (1059-1068), Online publication date: 1-Dec-2014.
Index Terms
- Regulating Code: Good Governance and Better Regulation in the Information Age
Recommendations
The challenges of regulating warez trading
Deviance and the internet: New challenges for social scienceThis article analyzes the policy challenges of legally conforming the behavior of warez traders. The article discusses the motivations for warez trading, how criminalizing the behavior may counterproductively encourage it, and why legislators and ...
Regulating electronic communications with government: improving the architecture or impeding the dialog?
ICEC '03: Proceedings of the 5th international conference on Electronic commerceUnder the Government Paperwork Elimination Act (GPEA), the US now requires all federal agencies to establish policies to permit their constituents to use electronic media in their interactions with government. What started out as an initiative to remove ...
Regulating the electronic marketplace through extraterritorial legislation: Google and eBay in the line of fire of French judges
TO INFINITY AND BEYOND: LAW AND TECHNOLOGY IN HARMONYIf the Internet is not the cause of the current normative crisis suffered by states, it is one of the best examples of the regulatory difficulties experienced by public authorities, whose legitimacy to regulate behaviour is seriously challenged. This ...