Capacity over capacitance for reliable energy harvesting sensors

ABSTRACT

Today, most sensors that harvest energy from indoor solar, ambient RF, or thermal gradients buffer small amounts of energy in capacitors as they intermittently work through a sensing task. While the utilization of capacitors for energy storage affords these systems indefinite lifetimes, their low energy capacity necessitates complex intermittent programming models for state retention and energy management. However, recent advances in battery technology lead us to reevaluate the impact that increased energy storage capacity may have on the necessity of these programming models and the reliability of energy harvesting sensors.

In this paper, we propose a capacity-based framework to help structure energy harvesting sensor design, analyze the impact of capacity on key reliability metrics using a data-driven simulation, and consider how backup energy storage alters the design space. We find that for many designs that utilize solar energy harvesting, increasing energy storage capacity to 1-10 mWh can obviate the need for intermittent programming techniques, augment the total harvested energy by 1.4-2.3x, and improve the availability of a sensor by 1.3-2.6x. We also show that a hybrid design using energy harvesting with a secondary-cell battery and a backup primary-cell battery can achieve 2-4x the lifetime of primary-cell only designs while eliminating the failure modes present in energy harvesting systems. Finally, we implement an indoor, solar energy harvesting sensor based on our analysis and find that its behavior aligns with our simulation's predictions.

References

1. J. Adkins, B. Campbell, S. DeBruin, B. Ghena, B. Kempke, N. Klugman, Y.-s. Kuo, D. Natarajan, P. Pannuto, T. Zachariah, and others 2015. Demo: Michigan's IoT Toolkit (SenSys'15).
2. J. Adkins, B. Ghena, N. Jackson, P. Pannuto, S. Rohrer, B. Campbell, and P. Dutta 2018. The Signpost Platform for City-Scale Sensing (IPSN'18).
3. Analog Devices. ADP5091 Datasheet. http://www.analog.com/media/en/technical-documentation/data-sheets/ADP5091-5092.pdf. (2017).
4. AVX. TPS Series Capacitor Datasheet. http://datasheets.avx.com/TPS.pdf. (2018).
5. I. Belharouak, G. M. Koenig, and K. Amine, Electrochemistry and safety of Li4Ti5O12 and graphite anodes paired with LiMn2O4 for hybrid electric vehicle Li-ion battery applications. Journal of Power Sources 196, 23 (2011).
6. M. Brunell, B. Hanauer, M. Loveridge, R. Dashwood, and R. Bhagat 2016. Effect of Zero Volt Storage on Commercial Lithium Titanate Cells. In Meeting Abstracts.
7. A. B. Brush, B. Lee, R. Mahajan, S. Agarwal, S. Saroiu, and C. Dixon 2011. Home Automation in the Wild: Challenges and Opportunities (CHI '11).
8. B. Campbell and P. Dutta 2014. An Energy-harvesting Sensor Architecture and Toolkit for Building Monitoring and Event Detection (BuildSys'14).
9. A. Colin, G. Harvey, B. Lucia, and A. P. Sample, An energy-interference-free hardware-software debugger for intermittent energy-harvesting systems. ACM SIGOPS Operating Systems Review 50, 2 (2016).
10. A. Colin, E. Ruppel, and B. Lucia 2018. A Reconfigurable Energy Storage Architecture for Energy-harvesting Devices (ASPLOS '18).
11. P. Corke, P. Valencia, P. Si, T. Wark, and L. Overs 2007. Long-duration solar-powered wireless sensor networks (SenSys'07).
12. S. DeBruin, B. Campbell, and P. Dutta 2013. Monjolo: An energy-harvesting energy meter architecture (SenSys'13).
13. W. K. Edwards and R. E. Grinter 2001. At Home with Ubiquitous Computing: Seven Challenges (UbiComp '01).
14. M. Gorlatova, A. Wallwater, and G. Zussman, Networking low-power energy harvesting devices: Measurements and algorithms. IEEE Transactions on Mobile Computing 12, 9 (2013).
15. J. Hester, L. Sitanayah, and J. Sorber 2015. Tragedy of the Coulombs: Federating Energy Storage for Tiny, Intermittently-Powered Sensors (SenSys '15).
16. J. Hester and J. Sorber 2017. Flicker: Rapid Prototyping for the Batteryless Internet-of-Things (SenSys '17).
17. J. Hester and J. Sorber 2017. The Future of Sensing is Batteryless, Intermittent, and Awesome (SenSys '17).
18. J. Hester, K. Storer, and J. Sorber 2017. Timely Execution on Intermittently Powered Batteryless Sensors (SenSys '17).
19. HuaHui New Energy. LTO Battery Specification. http://www.batteryspace.com/prod-specs/7455.pdf. (2013).
20. HuaHui New Energy. LTO Battery Catalog. Self hosted. Removed for Anonymity.. (2018).
21. N. Jackson, J. Adkins, and P. Dutta 2018. Reconsidering Batteries in Energy Harvesting Sensing (ENSsys'18).
22. X. Jiang, J. Polastre, and D. Culler 2005. Perpetual environmentally powered sensor networks (IPSN'05).
23. A. Kansal, J. Hsu, S. Zahedi, and M. B. Srivastava, Power management in energy harvesting sensor networks. ACM Transactions on Embedded Computing Systems (TECS) 6, 4 (2007).
24. H.-S. Kim, M. P. Andersen, K. Chen, S. Kumar, W. J. Zhao, K. Ma, and D. E. Culler 2018. System Architecture Directions for Post-SoC/32-bit Networked Sensors. In Proceedings of the 16th ACM Conference on Embedded Networked Sensor Systems. ACM.
25. K. Kiningham, M. Horowitz, P. Levis, and D. Boneh 2016. CESEL: Securing a Mote for 20 Years (EWSN '16).
26. F. Larsson and B.-E. Mellander, Abuse by External Heating, Overcharge and Short Circuiting of Commercial Lithium-Ion Battery Cells. Journal of The Electrochemical Society 161, 10 (2014).
27. P. Levis, N. Patel, D. Culler, and S. Shenker 2004. Trickle: A self-regulating algorithm for code propagation and maintenance in wireless sensor networks (NSDI '04).
28. K. Lin, J. Yu, J. Hsu, S. Zahedi, D. Lee, J. Friedman, A. Kansal, V. Raghunathan, and M. Srivastava 2005. Heliomote: enabling long-lived sensor networks through solar energy harvesting (SenSys'05).
29. B. Lucia, V. Balaji, A. Colin, K. Maeng, and E. Ruppel 2017. Intermittent Computing: Challenges and Opportunities. In SNAPL.
30. B. Lucia and B. Ransford, A simpler, safer programming and execution model for intermittent systems. ACM SIGPLAN Notices 50, 6 (2015).
31. A. Mainwaring, D. Culler, J. Polastre, R. Szewczyk, and J. Anderson 2002. Wireless sensor networks for habitat monitoring (WSNA'02).
32. R. Margolies, M. Gorlatova, J. Sarik, G. Stanje, J. Zhu, P. Miller, M. Szczodrak, B. Vigraham, L. Carloni, P. Kinget, and others, Energy-harvesting active networked tags (EnHANTs): Prototyping and experimentation (TOSN).
33. P. Martin, Z. Charbiwala, and M. Srivastava 2012. DoubleDip: Leveraging thermoelectric harvesting for low power monitoring of sporadic water use (SenSys'12).
34. Maxim Integrated. MAX17222 Datasheet. https://datasheets.maximintegrated.com/en/ds/MAX17220-MAX17225.pdf. (2017).
35. Murata. DMF Series EDLCs. https://www.murata.com/en-us/products/productdata/8796857270302/MFCDSF1E.pdf. (2016).
36. N. Omar, M. A. Monem, Y. Firouz, J. Salminen, J. Smekens, O. Hegazy, H. Gaulous, G. Mulder, P. V. d. Bossche, T. Coosemans, and J. V. Mierlo, Lithium iron phosphate based battery---Assessment of the aging parameters and development of cycle life model. Applied Energy 113 (2014).
37. J. Polastre, R. Szewczyk, and D. Culler 2005. Telos: enabling ultra-low power wireless research (IPSN'05).
38. Pressac. Pressac CO2 Sensor Datasheet. http://www.pressac.com/help/CO2TemperatureAndHumiditySensor.html. (2017).
39. H. Raisigel, G. Chabanis, I. Ressejac, and M. Trouillon 2010. Autonomous wireless sensor node for building climate conditioning application (SENSORCOMM'10).
40. B. Ransford, J. Sorber, and K. Fu, Mementos: System support for long-running computation on RFID-scale devices. Acm Sigplan Notices 47, 4 (2012).
41. E. Shehan and W. K. Edwards 2007. Home Networking and HCI: What Hath God Wrought? (CHI '07).
42. Shenzhen Hibatt Technology. Mini LiFePo4 Battery. https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/Mini-LiFePO4-battery-10130-30mAh-3_60717575578.html. (2018).
43. Texas Instruments. BQ25505 Datasheet. http://www.ti.com/lit/ds/symlink/bq25505.pdf. (2015).
44. J. Wang, P. Liu, J. Hicks-Garner, E. Sherman, S. Soukiazian, M. Verbrugge, H. Tataria, J. Musser, and P. Finamore, Cycle-life model for graphite-LiFePO4 cells. Journal of Power Sources 196, 8 (2011).
45. L. Yerva, B. Campbell, A. Bansal, T. Schmid, and P. Dutta 2012. Grafting Energy-harvesting Leaves Onto the Sensornet Tree (IPSN'12).

Index Terms

• Computer systems organization

  • Embedded and cyber-physical systems

    • Sensor networks

• Hardware

  • Communication hardware, interfaces and storage

    • Sensors and actuators

  • Power and energy

    • Energy generation and storage

      • Batteries

      • Reusable energy storage