Toward a conceptual framework of agile methods: a study of agility in different disciplines

ABSTRACT

Since the software crisis of the 1960's, numerous methodologies have been developed to impose a disciplined process upon software development. It is now widely accepted that these methodologies are unsuccessful and unpopular due to their increasingly bureaucratic nature. Many researchers and practitioners are calling for these heavyweight methodologies to be replaced by agile methods. The Agile Manifesto was put forward in 2001, and several method instantiations, such as XP, SCRUM and Crystal exist. Each adheres to some principles of the Agile Manifesto and disregards others. This paper proposes that these Agile Manifesto principles are insufficiently grounded in theory, and are largely naive to the concept of agility outside the field of software development. This paper aims to develop a comprehensive framework of software development agility, through a thorough review of agility across many disciplines. We then elaborate and evaluate the framework in a software development context, through a review of software related research over the last 30 years.

References

1. Baskerville, R.; Travis, J.; Truex, D., (1992) Systems without method: the impact of new technologies on information systems development projects., in The Impact of Computer Supported Technologies on Information Systems Development, K. Lyytinen, Editor. 1992, Elsevier Science Publishers: North Holland. p. 241--269.
2. Breu, K.; Hemingway, C.; Strathern, M., (2001) Workforce agility: the new employee strategy for the knowledge economy. Journal of Information Technology, 2001. 17: p. 21--31.
3. Burgess, T., (1994) Making the Leap to Agility: Defining and Achieving Agile Manufacturing through Business Process Redesign and Business Network Redesign. International Journal of Operations and Production Management., 1994. 14(11): p. 23--34.
4. Childerhouse, P.; Disney, S.; Towill, D., (2000) Speeding Up the Progress Curve Towards Effective Supply Chain Management. International Journal of Supply Chain Management, 2000. 5(3): p. 176--186.
5. Christopher, M., (2000) The agile supply chain: competing in volatile markets. Industrial Marketing Management, 2000. 29(1): p. 37--44.
6. Christopher, M., (2000) The agile supply chin: competing in volatile markets. Industrial Marketing Management, 2000. 29(1): p. 37--44.
7. Cockburn, A., (2002) Agile Software Development Joins the "Would-Be" Crowd. Cutter IT Journal, 2002. Vol. 15(1): p. 6--12.
8. Conboy, K.; Fitzgerald, B. (2004) Towards a Conceptual Framework of Agile Methods. in XP and Agile Conference. 2004. Alberta, Canada.
9. Correa, H., (1994) The Flexibility of Technological and Human Resources in Automotive Manufacturing. Journal of Integrated Manufacturing Systems, 1994. 5(1): p. 33--40.
10. De Vor, R.; Mills, J., (1995) Agile Manufacturing. American Society of Mechanical Engineers, MED, 1995. 2(2): p. 977.
11. Drucker, P., (1995) The Information That Executives Truly Need. Harvard Business Review, 1995. Jan/Feb.
12. Eppink, D., (1978) Managing the Unforeseen: A Study of Flexibility. 1978, Vrije Universiteit.: Amsterdam.
13. Fitzgerald, B., (1996) Formalised systems development methodologies: a critical perspective. Information Systems Journal, 1996. 6(1): p. 3--23.
14. Fitzgerald, B., (1994) The systems development dilemma: whether to adopt formalised systems development methodologies or not?, in Proceedings of the Second European Conference on Information Systems, W. Baets, Editor. 1994, Nijenrode University Press: Holland. p. 691--706.
15. Fowler, M.; Highsmith, J., (2001) The Agile Manifesto. Software Development, 2001. August.
16. Gerwin, D., (1993) Manufacturing Flexibility: A Strategic Perspective. Management Science, 1993. 39(4): p. 395--410.
17. Golden, W.; Powell, P., (2000) Towards a Definition of Flexibility: In Search of the Holy Grail? Omega, 2000. 28(2000): p. 373--384.
18. Goldman, S.; Nagel, R., (1993) Management, technology and agility: the emergence of a new era in manufacturing. International Journal of Technology Management, 1993. 8(1/2): p. 18--38.
19. Goldman, S.; Nagel, R.; Preiss, K., (1995) Agile Competitors and Virtual Organisations. Strategies for Enriching the Customer. 1995, New York, NY.: Von Nostrand Reinhold.
20. Goldman, S., et al., (1991) Iacocca Institute: 21st Century Manufacturing Enterprise Strategy: An Industry Led View. Vol. 1/2. 1991: Iacocca Institute, Bethlehem, PA.
21. Goudswaard, A.; de Nanteuil, M., (2000) Flexibility and Working Conditions: a qualitative and comparative study in seven EU Member States. 2000, European Foundation for Living and Working Conditions, EF0007.
22. Gunasekaran, A.; Tirtiroglou, E.; Wolstencroft, V., (2002) An Investigation into the application of agile manufacturing in an aerospace company. Elsevier, Technovation, 2002. 22: p. 405--415.
23. Gustavsson, S., (1984) Flexibility and Productivity in Complex Production Processes. International Journal of Production Research, 1984. 22(5): p. 801--808.
24. Hashimoto, T., (1980) Robustness, Reliability, Resilience and Vulnerability Criteria for Planning. 1980, Cornell University.
25. Hashimoto, T.; Loucks, D.; Stedinger, J., (1982) Robustness of Water Resources Systems. Water Resources Research, 1982. 18(1): p. 21--26.
26. Hong, M.; Payander, S.; Gruver, W., (1996) Modelling and Analysis of flexible fixturing systems for agile manufacturing. Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man and Cybernetics, 1996. 2: p. 1231--1236.
27. Huang, C., (1999) An agile approach to logical network analysis in decision support systems. Decision Support Systems, 1999. 25(1): p. 53--70.
28. Institute, I., (1991) 21st Century Manufacturing Enterprise Strategy, An Industry-led View. Iacocca Institute, 1991. 1.
29. Katayama, H.; Bennet, D., (1999) Agility, adaptability and leanness: a comparison of concepts and a study of practice. International Journal of Production Economics, 1999. 62(1/2): p. 43--51.
30. Kusak, A.; He, D., (1997) Design for agile assembly: an operational perspective. International Journal of Production Research, 1997. 35(1): p. 157--178.
31. Lindbergh, P., (1990) Strategic manufacturing management: a proactive approach. International Journal of Operations and Production Management, 1990. 10(2): p. 94--106.
32. Nagel, R.; Dove, R., (1991) 21st Century Manufacturing. Enterprise Strategy. 1991, Iacocca Institute, Lehigh University Bethlehem, PA.
33. Naylor, J.; Naim, M.; Berry, D., (1999) Leagility: Integrating the Lean and Agile Manufacturing Paradigm in the Total Supply Chain. Engineering Costs and Production Economics, 1999. 62: p. 107--118.
34. Ohno, T., (1988) The Toyota Production System: Beyond Large Scale Production. 1988, Portland, OR: Productivity Press.
35. Piore, M., (1989) Corporate Reform in American Manufacturing and the Challenge to Economic Reform. 1989: Mimeo, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
36. Preiss, K.; Goldman, S.; Nagel, R., (1996) Cooperate to compete: building agile business relationships. 1996, New York: Vn Nostrand Reinhold.
37. Sharafi, H.; Zhang, Z., (1999) A method for achieving agility in manufacturing organisations: an introduction. International Journal of Production Economics, 1999. 62(1/2): p. 7--22.
38. Tan, B., (1998) Agile Manufacturing and Management of Variability. International Transactions on Operational Research, 1998. 5(5): p. 375--388.
39. Towill, D.; Christopher, M., (2002) The Supply Chain Strategy Conundrum: To Be Lean Or Agile or To Be Lean and Agile. International Journal of Logistics: Research and Applications, 2002. 5(3).
40. Upton, D. M., (1995) Flexibility as Process Mobility: The Management of Plant Capabilities for Quick Response Manufacturing. Journal of Operations Management, 1995. 12(205--224).
41. Van Oyen, M.; Gel, E.; Hopp, W., (2001) Performance opportunity for workforce agility in collaborative and non-collaborative work systems. IEEE Transactions, 2001. 33(9): p. 761--77.
42. Volberda, H., (1998) Building the Flexible Firm: How to Remain Competitive. 1998, New York: Oxford University Press.
43. Womack, J.; Jones, D.; Roos, D., (1990) The Machine That Changed the World. 1990, New York: Rawson Associates.
44. Young, K., et al., (2001) Agile Control Systems. In: Proc Instn Mech Engrs, 2001. 215(D).
45. Yusuf, Y.; Sarhadi, M.; Gunasekaran, A., (1999) Agile manufacturing: the drivers, concepts and attributes. International Journal of Production Economics, 1999. 62(1): p. 23--32.
46. Zain, M.; Kassim, N.; Mokhtar, E., (2002) Use of IT nd IS for organisational agility in Malaysian firms. Singapore Management Review, 2002. 25(1).

Index Terms

• Social and professional topics

  • Professional topics

    • Management of computing and information systems

      • Implementation management

        • Pricing and resource allocation

      • Project and people management

• Software and its engineering

  • Software creation and management